2010
C - Stanislav Gatiyatuli (OTT)
LW - Jeff Freisen (MIN)
RW - Radek Dvorak (MIN)
D - Bryan McCabe (PHI)
D - Brad Stuart (CHI)
G - Graham Baron-Monte (WPG)
2009
C - Andrei Taratukhin (NYI)
LW - Patrik Elias (NYI)
RW - Radek Dvorak (MIN)
D - Bryan McCabe (PHI)
D - Brad Stuart (CHI)
G - J-S Aubin (CHI)
2008
C - Marian Gaborik (CAL)
LW - Jeff Friesen (MIN)
RW - Radek Dvorak (MIN)
D - Karel Rachunek (CAL)
D - Ed Jovanovski (MIN)
G - Patrick Lalime (NYI)
2007
C - Marian Gaborik (CAL)
LW - Jeff Friesen (WSH)
RW - Brad Richards (VAN)
D - Chris Pronger (VAN)
D - Ed Jovanovski (MIN)
G - Marty Turco (DET)
2006
C - Marc Savard (DET)
LW - Martin Havlat (VAN)
RW - Milan Hejduk (WSH)
D - Chris Pronger (VAN)
D - Pavel Kubina (TB)
G - Roberto Luongo (VAN)
2005
C - Vincent Lecavalier (VAN)
LW - Jeff Friesen (WSH)
RW - Radek Dvorak (MIN)
D - Nick Lidstrom (DET)
D - Ed Jovanovski (MIN)
G - Fred Brathwaite (OTT)
2004
C - Joe Sakic (SJ)
LW - Jeff Friesen (SJ)
RW - Milan Hejduk (NYR)
D - Nick Lidstrom (DET)
D - Chris Pronger (VAN)
G - Roberto Luongo (VAN)
2003
C - Alexei Yashin (CHI)
LW - Paul Kariya (NSH)
RW - Alexei Kovalev (PIT)
D - Janne Niinimaa (SJ)
D - Chris Pronger (VAN)
G - Evgeni Nabokov (TB)
2002
C - Mats Sundin (COL)
LW - Paul Kariya (NSH)
RW - Jaromir Jagr (CHI)
D - Brian Leetch (BOS)
D - Eric Desjardins (NJ)
G - Patrick Lalime (NYI)
2001
C - Joe Sakic (COL)
LW - Paul Kariya (NSH)
RW - Jaromir Jagr (CHI)
D - Brian Leetch (BOS)
D - Jamie Allison (PHI)
G - Curtis Joseph (BOS)
Post Season First Team All-Stars